Taxpayers have the right to challenge IRS and NYS audit results and secure the correct outcome.
🧾 The Right to Appeal Tax Decisions — IRS & NYS Appeal Success Story
Receiving a tax audit notice is stressful enough. However, when the government issues a decision you don’t agree with — especially one that costs you thousands — the fear can quickly become overwhelming.
In fact, under the IRS, Taxpayer Bill of Rights you have the right to appeal a tax decision in an independent forum.
With the right representation, you can correct mistakes and save real money. New York State offers similar protections. As a result, taxpayers can challenge unfair outcomes and often succeed.
🧩 Real Client Story: How We Challenged the NYS Audit Results
My client,, Lisa B., is a licensed mental health professional serving vulnerable individuals in her community. New York State selected her for audit and questioned several of her legitimate business deductions.
As a result, they reduced the tax refund she was entitled to.
Like many taxpayers, Lisa didn’t understand:
-
Why deductions were being denied
-
How the State calculated the changes
-
What her rights were moving forward
That confusion is very common.
However, thankfully — your right to appeal protects you.
Furthermore, when she hired me, we immediately exercised her right to challenge the audit results and request a new, fair review.
We:
-
Prepared a professional narrative explaining her therapy practice
-
Submitted detailed supporting documentation
-
Identified audit errors in the State’s findings
-
Filed a formal audit reconsideration request
As a result, the outcome was significant:
✅ Deductions reinstated
✅ Audit position reversed
✅ Refund of $3,275.98 issued to Lisa
✅ Her case closed in her favor
Most importantly, this isn’t speculation. In other words, we have the official NYS Adjustment Notice documenting the corrected refund amount.
✅ CASE RESULT SNAPSHOT
| Client Profile: | Mental health professional |
|---|---|
| Issue: | NYS audit denied legitimate deductions |
| Action: | Audit reconsideration appeal |
| Outcome: | ✅ Deductions reinstated |
| Refund Issued: | ✅ $3,275.98 |
| Rights Used: | Right to Appeal Tax Decisions (IRS & NYS equivalents) |
⚖️ Right to Appeal – IRS vs. Appeal Rights – NYS
The IRS guarantees access to the Independent Office of Appeals. Additionally, they must explain their decisions and pause collection during a review. Taxpayers may also take certain cases to U.S. Tax Court if needed.
New York State works differently. Even so, taxpayers still have options. For example, they can disagree with an audit report, request a review, or appeal through the Bureau of Conciliation and Mediation Services.
If necessary, they can pursue an independent decision at the Division of Tax Appeals.
Consequently, taxpayers are not stuck with an incorrect result from either agency.
🎯 Why Audit Reconsideration Works
A strong appeal isn’t emotional — instead, it is organized, documented, and strategic. Additionally, reconsideration helps correct errors when information was missing or misunderstood during the initial audit.
Since I worked as a former NYS bank examiner, I know:
-
Exactly how auditors think
-
What qualifies as acceptable evidence
-
How to eliminate red flags
-
When to escalate and when to negotiate
Consequently, that insider perspective is often the difference between owing thousands and getting thousands back. Meanwhile, taxpayers who do nothing usually end up paying far more than they should.
✅ The Bottom Line
If you disagree with a tax decision — whether from the IRS or New York State — you have the right to appeal. Better yet, as Lisa’s case proves, you can absolutely win.
Even so, timing matters, and delays can weaken your rights.
That said, like Lisa, you can absolutely win.
Need Help Appealing an IRS or NYS Tax Decision?
At W. Scully, CPA, P.C. and Tax Resolution Experts of America, we help taxpayers avoid the serious consequences of not acting on their appeals case.
For that reason, you don’t need to take no for an answer from the IRS or NYS.
Simply put, we protect your rights, build the strongest case possible, and fight for the correct outcome.
👉 Click to book a confidential consultation today;
👉 Or call us directly at (718) 938-4601 or visit W. Scully, CPA, P.C.
Want more blog content? Find more here.
Connect with me, everywhere:
Learn about Wayne Scully CPA here
Fill out the form below to connect with us now:
